Drive Failure Warning Signs and What to Do Next
By GigaGone Editorial Team Review by GigaGone Editorial Team Most recently reviewed Published Topic: Drives & NAS
Warning signs of a failing drive include clicking or grinding noises, repeated freezes, files that will not open, drives that disconnect, and SMART warnings. If you see them, stop using the drive, copy what you can to another device, and do not attempt repairs yourself. Some drives fail with no warning at all, so keep a separate backup.
Part of the guide: External Drives, SSDs and NAS: A Beginner's Guide
General information, not professional IT, security or legal advice; for a failing drive, a ransomware incident or a compromised account, contact the vendor’s support, your IT provider or a qualified professional. Reviewed by the editorial desk against the cited sources.
A drive that is failing usually gives hints first, but not always. This page is part of our external drives, SSDs and NAS guide and covers the signs, the safe first steps and the point at which to stop and call a professional.
Warning signs of a failing hard drive or SSD
- Noises (hard drives): clicking, grinding, beeping or repeated spin-up and spin-down.
- Slowdowns and freezes: copying takes much longer, the computer hangs when the drive is accessed.
- File problems: files that will not open, vanish or are corrupted; folders that become empty.
- Disconnects: the drive drops out of Finder or File Explorer, or does not appear.
- Errors: repeated disk errors, failed backups, a drive that becomes read-only.
- SMART or Disk Utility warnings: the drive or operating system reports a pending failure.
- Heat or smell: unusual heat or a burning smell. Unplug it immediately.
Not every drive gives warning. In Backblaze’s data, five SMART attributes (5, 187, 188, 197 and 198) with non-zero raw values flagged 76.7% of failed drives versus 4.2% of working ones, but 23.3% of failed drives showed no warning at all. A clean SMART report is not a clean bill of health.
What to do first
- Stop using the drive. Close apps that use it and, for a clicking drive, power it off. Further use can make things worse.
- Copy your most important files now, to a different drive or computer. Do not install, defragment, clean up or reformat on the suspect drive.
- If the drive still works, clone or copy everything once, preferring the irreplaceable files first. Copying, rather than running repair tools, is the safe order.
- Do not run repair tools until your data is copied. Apple notes that Disk Utility’s First Aid fixes formatting and directory errors, and that a disk it warns is about to fail cannot be repaired: back up and replace it.
- Do not reformat or erase. Apple’s guide states that formatting erases all files on the disk.
- Replace the drive and restore from your copy. See our backup guide and the three-copy backup method so one failure never costs you everything.
What not to do
- Do not open a hard drive, tap it, freeze it or try home-recovery tricks.
- Do not keep rebooting to see if it “comes back”.
- Do not run repeated scans, which can stress a weak drive.
- Do not rely on RAID or a mirror as a safety net, because RAID is not a backup.
SSD and flash drive signs
SSDs and USB sticks have no moving parts, so noise is not a sign. Look for sudden disappearance, read-only behaviour, repeated errors, corrupted files, very slow writes and SMART warnings. Wear is a separate, slower issue covered in do SSDs and USB sticks wear out.
When to call a professional
Call the vendor’s support (the warranty may cover replacement) or a reputable data recovery service if:
- the drive clicks, grinds or is not detected;
- it holds data you cannot replace and you have no other copy;
- repair attempts or copying keep failing;
- the drive is in a NAS or array showing multiple faults.
Ask about the price and the policy if nothing is recovered before shipping the drive. GigaGone does not offer recovery. Our data loss and recovery guide explains the basics, and our decimal-vs-binary size guide explains why a drive reports a different capacity than its label.
Questions readers ask
What are the first signs of a failing hard drive?
Common signs are clicking, grinding or repeated spin-up noises, very slow file access, frequent freezes, files that fail to open or are corrupted, the drive disconnecting at random and operating-system errors about the disk. Any of these is a reason to copy your data to another device straight away and stop using the drive for anything else.
Can an SSD fail without warning?
Yes. SSDs have no moving parts to make noise, and some fail suddenly, disappearing from the system or becoming read-only. SMART data may show warnings, but Backblaze found that 23.3% of failed drives in its data showed no SMART warning. Keep a separate backup of anything you cannot replace.
Does a SMART warning mean the drive is dead?
No, but treat it as serious. A SMART warning or Apple's 'about to fail' message means the drive's own monitoring found a problem. Apple advises backing up your data and replacing the disk, since it cannot be repaired. Copy your files first, and do not keep using the drive as your only copy.
Should I keep using a clicking drive?
No. Switch it off or unplug it. Every extra spin can damage the platters or read heads and make data harder to recover. If the data matters and you have no other copy, stop and contact a professional recovery service or the manufacturer. Do not open the drive, freeze it or try repair tricks.
Can I fix a failing drive myself?
We do not recommend it. Repair utilities such as First Aid can fix directory errors, but they do not fix failing hardware, and heavy scanning can stress a weak drive. Do not open a hard drive, swap parts or reformat it. Copy files off first, then replace the drive or seek professional help.
How do I check a drive's SMART status?
On a Mac, Disk Utility shows the drive's S.M.A.R.T. status in its information panel for supported drives. On Windows, the manufacturer's tool or a trusted SMART utility can show it. Treat any warning as a prompt to back up. A clean status does not prove the drive is healthy.
When should I call a data recovery professional?
Call one when the drive makes noises, is not detected, or holds data you cannot replace and have no backup of, and you have stopped using it. Ask about pricing and a no-recovery-no-fee policy before sending it. GigaGone does not provide recovery services.
Further reading
- Backblaze: What SMART stats tell us about hard drives (backblaze.com)
- Apple Support: Repair a storage device in Disk Utility on Mac (support.apple.com)
- Apple Support: Format a disk for Windows computers using Disk Utility on Mac (support.apple.com)
Worth reading next
- External Drives, SSDs and NAS: A Beginner's Guide
Learn the difference between external hard drives, portable SSDs, and home NAS boxes, with failure-rate context and advice on choosing backup hardware.
- Backblaze Drive Stats Explained for Home Users
How to read Backblaze's public Drive Stats: drive days, annualized failure rate, confidence and sample size, and what it means for a home backup drive.
- exFAT, NTFS and APFS: Formatting an External Drive for Windows, Mac and Linux
Which file system for an external drive? exFAT works on Windows and Mac; NTFS and APFS each favour one. Limits and steps, from Microsoft and Apple.
- How to Choose an External Drive for Backups
Pick an external drive for backups: capacity rule of thumb, HDD vs SSD, format, encryption and the habits that matter more than the model.
- HDD vs SSD for Backups: What the Failure Data Says
Should a backup drive be a hard disk or an SSD? What Backblaze's published failure data does and does not show, and a simple pick for home backups.
- NAS vs External Drive for Home Backup
NAS or external hard drive for home backup? Compare cost, setup, access, and why RAID is not a backup, with a pick for each kind of household.